Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Banteay Meanchey governor’s criticism of hospital head leads to close examination

Banteay Meanchey governor’s criticism of hospital head leads to close examination

Content image - Phnom Penh Post
Banteay Meanchey provincial governor Um Reatrey donates blood. FB

Banteay Meanchey governor’s criticism of hospital head leads to close examination

Officials from the Banteay Meanchey provincial Department of Health involved with internal oversight said they have discovered “irregularities” in the management of the Cambodia-Japan Friendship Hospital in Mongkol Borei district under director Chan Vuthy Navuth.

The scrutiny followed critical Facebook comments by provincial governor Um Reatrey.

“No decision has been made yet as to whether Chan Vuthy Navuth will be removed from his post as hospital director.

“The technical team is still investigating and gathering detailed information on Vuthy Navuth’s performance before filing a report to the governor to review as required by the civil service statutes,” provincial health department director Le Chan Sangvat told The Post on September 8.

Chan Sangvat said provincial health officials are required to follow the code of professional ethics in accordance with the civil service statutes. The department must first investigate and find out what if anything has occurred as claimed and what the severity of the problem might be.

“If he has made mistakes we will submit a report to the provincial governor so that he can decide on any disciplinary punishment in accordance with the civil service statutes,” he said.

Chan Sangvat said the provincial health department had transferred all of Vuthy Navuth’s responsibilities to provincial administration officials while the investigation is ongoing.

“Chan Vuthy Navuth has not previously been implicated in any misconduct or given any warnings in that regard, so as far as I know he has done a good job. But it can be a lot of work to be the leader and we’re taking a closer look so that if we find any problems we can solve them,” he said.

He continued that some problems may not be caused by Vuthy Navuth and could be the fault of his subordinates if they have been negligent in their duties, but as the leader Vuthy Navuth must also bear some responsibility for the actions of his subordinates.

“This mistake may not be a big deal, but as the person in charge, the hospital director has to take responsibility for it,” he said.

Reatrey did not immediately respond to a request for comment on September 7.

“Today [September 4] at 10:50pm, I donated blood to save Inly An, a lieutenant colonel in the bodyguard unit of Samdech Techo [Prime Minister Hun Sen].

“The lieutenant colonel came to Banteay Meanchey to have surgery at the Mongkol Borei hospital but its director said that in principle he would have to look for a blood donor to replace any blood used and pay for services prior to surgery even if the patient is in serious condition,” he said in his Facebook post.

“How can the management be making decisions like this? The director ignores his ethical duties and doesn’t know how to do his job. This is not the first time such a problem has come up, it has happened many times. People have always complained about the provision of services at the hospital with Chan Vuthy Navuth as the head,” he added.

Sum Chankea, provincial coordinator for rights group Adhoc, said the governor should not have posted about the situation publicly on his Facebook page and should have instead called a meeting or made recommendations through the appropriate channels.

“Sometimes people post things to social media that are based on what they are feeling rather than the facts of the situation and this post is a public expression of his anger.

“In principle, it is within the governor’s power to address the work performance of any civil servants [but] this should be in a due process where he can consider the input of others who are familiar with all of his work and not just one particular incident,” he said.


  • Tensions high ahead of historic Kun Khmer match up

    The long-awaited November 5 matchup between Kun Khmer legend Prum Samnang and Myanmar-Canadian boxer Dave Leduc has become the most anticipated fight of the year. The Wurkz Sena Kun Khmer promotion, which will be held at the Town Arena at Chip Mong 271 Megamall, will see six

  • Manet: Cambodia safe for travel

    Prime Minister Hun Manet acknowledged that Cambodia and China have cooperated to tackle internet scamming, fraud and other cross border crimes, but insisted that the “Kingdom of Wonders” is completely peaceful and safe. He welcomed tourists to come and explore its rich heritage. During a

  • UNESCO formally list Battambang gastronomy

    Battambang, renowned for its cultural heritage, has achieved a significant milestone as the first Cambodian municipality to join the UNESCO Creative Cities Network (UCCN). The UCCN unites nearly 300 cities prioritising creativity and cultural industries in local development plans and international cooperation. On World Cities Day,

  • Cambodia pivots to solar, wind energy

    Cambodia is planning a move towards solar and wind energy to meet its rising power demands, according to Minister of Mines and Energy Keo Rottanak. On the sidelines of the Singapore International Energy Week event held recently, Rottanak emphasised the urgency of diversifying Cambodia’s

  • Angkor causeway symbol of Cambodia-Japan ties

    In a historic moment marking another milestone in the 70-year-long diplomatic relations between Cambodia and Japan, King Norodom Sihamoni celebrated the formal inauguration of a causeway located to the west of the world-renowned Angkor Wat. While presiding over the November 4 ceremony, the King emphasised the

  • Kep selected for ‘world-class’ 2.7km beach development

    Kep province has been selected as the first site of a new coastal development initiative, with a “world-class” 2.7km beach planned for the near future. The Kep Provincial Administration met with the National Committee for Coastal Management and Development to discuss the development of the